Remember when I posted the video of the vegetable orchestra? I, along with Woody, was captivated by the concept and the sound. “Using things differently,” as they say below, thinking about things differently, living differently than usual is important to me and I love to see this sort of creative energy. I confess, though, that when I first viewed the video my knee-jerk reaction was that it seemed like a waste of food given that there are people starving all over the world. Tracy pointed out that carving instruments out of vegetables is a more ecologically sound endeavor than producing instruments the other way, and I knew that he was right.
Today, I was made aware of the vegetable orchestra website, so I checked it out and saw that they address the issue on their questions and answers page:
isn't it an ethical problem to play on vegetable instruments while elsewhere people die of starvation?
we have heard this question very often. if you are really concerned about the distribution of wealth then do something about it! read books about the real cause of hunger. change your own life and try to change politics. buy and support the right things. it is not people using vegetables differently than usual that make the world a bad place. it's all of us wanting too much. our own car, a new cellphone, a bigger house with air condition, more money...
actually our instruments cause less problems than traditional instruments, laptops, etc...
their production needs much less energy and resources and they are bio-degradable.
So, there you go. I thought it was a good answer. It’s certainly true that the real cause of hunger has nothing to do with a shortage of food and everything to do with distribution of wealth and the choices we all make everyday.
Thinking about this reminded me of a conversation that I had recently with a young woman who was tremendously poised and well-spoken. She is an environmentalist and describing how she came to her awareness about the cause she now works for, she said, “I realized that my consumption and my decisions do have impact beyond me. We have a global economy and that’s convenient because it keeps our prices down, but it’s foolhardy to pretend like there aren’t other ways that we interact with our global neighbors and one of the ways is that our consumption has a spill-over effect.”
When I was this woman’s age, there’s no way I could have put thoughts together and presented myself the way she did. I was so impressed by her and her mission and her outlook, which was overwhelmingly positive. She told me that her generation is tired of negativity, that they don’t feel the global situation is hopeless, that they’re working on an inclusive way to craft solutions.
I thought about her today as I shifted my awareness of the vegetable orchestra, and I thought about world hunger. It’s easy to get bogged down in the belief that the suffering in this world is too great, that we can’t undo the damage that has been done. It’s easy to fall victim to apathy or fear-mongering and feel paralyzed – unwilling to look head-on at the pain of others, the fallout of climate change, the line around the block at the soup kitchen, the homeless woman walking down the street, or the atrocity of human rights violations that play out on the nightly news, because we simply don’t know what to do about it.
The vegetable orchestra answer urges us to do something – change our own lives. We can, I believe, change our own lives, and thereby change the lives of others, and we can change them in small shifts, in leanings and moments. We don’t have to do everything. It’s not all or nothing. We can change the way we live in our own communities, in our own homes, in our own kitchens, and those changes will ripple out and be felt by the larger world.
We can even do something really, really small like clicking a button.
It’s a message not unlike the one I heard Mary Robinson deliver several months ago.
Mary Robinson, I believe is (very much like
Jimmy Carter*) a walking around breathing saint. I sat enraptured by her, not because she was the most dynamic speaker I’d ever heard, but because of her steady sure-footed compassionate work. Because she has seen the very worst the world has to offer and she has not given up. And because she is nice. She is
still a nice, warm and forgiving person.
Robinson directly addressed this issue, this feeling that the problems are too great, that the things we are able to do won’t really make a difference. Begin, Robinson told us, right here. Begin in your home, in your town.
“Everyone has duties to the community in which alone the free and full development of his or her personality is possible,” she said.
And she quoted these remarks made by
Eleanor Roosevelt (oh, how I love Eleanor Roosevelt! Remind me to tell you sometime about visiting her house) to the United Nations in March of 1953:
Where after all do universal human rights begin? In small places, close to home – so close and so small that they cannot be seen on any map of the world. Yet they are the world of the individual person: The neighborhood he lives in; the school or college he attends; the factory, farm or office where he works. Such are the places where every man, woman, and child seeks equal justice, equal opportunity, equal dignity without discrimination. Unless these rights have meaning there, they have little meaning anywhere. Without concerted citizen action to uphold them close to home, we shall look in vain for progress in the larger world.
Hunger is a human rights issue, whether here or in Africa or anywhere. The environment is a human rights issue. It’s all tied together, one big cosmic ball of cause and effect, and we are not, as individuals, powerless. Isn’t it good to think that we aren’t? I mean, what’s the point of thinking that we are? We have this amazing gift of free will. We have choice and each and every moment presents the opportunity to make a different one.
It’s just like the nun said to
Scott Baio last night, “The best thing you can do for your child is love his mother.”
What, you are thinking,
in the Sam Hill does that have to do with global human rights? Well, partially, I just really liked that message. Scott Baio showed his emotional side. It was very touching. But, I’m also thinking that it does relate to what I’m trying to say here – it’s the idea that it begins at home – the change we want to see—with something really simple and enormous--Love.
*On a side note, I love this story about Jimmy Carter. Maybe not so pacifist, but so what. The Elders are my super heroes.